Treatment in Kenyan rural health facilities: projected drug costs using the WHO-UNICEF integrated management of childhood illness (IMCI) guidelines.

Publisher: World Health Organization Country of Publication: Switzerland NLM ID: 7507052 Publication Model: Print Cited Medium: Print ISSN: 0042-9686 (Print) Linking ISSN: 00429686 NLM ISO Abbreviation: Bull World Health Organ Subsets: MEDLINE

Original Publication: Geneva : World Health Organization,

Practice Guidelines as Topic*; Child Health Services/*economics ; Drug Costs/*statistics & numerical data ; Drug Costs/*trends ; Health Care Costs/*statistics & numerical data ; Health Care Costs/*trends ; Rural Health Services/*economics; Child Health Services/trends ; Child, Preschool ; Delivery of Health Care, Integrated ; Forecasting ; Humans ; Infant ; Kenya ; Rural Health Services/trends ; World Health Organization

Guidelines for the integrated management of childhood illness (IMCI) in peripheral health facilities have been developed by WHO and UNICEF to improve the recognition and treatment of common causes of childhood death. To evaluate the impact of the guidelines on treatment costs, we compared the cost of drugs actually prescribed to a sample of 747 sick children aged 2-59 months in rural health facilities in western Kenya with the cost of drugs had the children been managed using the IMCI guidelines. The average cost of drugs actually prescribed per child was US$ 0.44 (1996 US$). Antibiotics were the most costly component, with phenoxymethylpenicillin syrup accounting for 59% of the cost of all the drugs prescribed. Of the 295 prescriptions for phenoxymethylpenicillin syrup, 223 (76%) were for treatment of colds or cough. The cost of drugs that would have been prescribed had the same children been managed with the IMCI guidelines ranged from US$ 0.16 per patient (based on a formulary of larger-dose tablets and a home remedy for cough) to US$ 0.39 per patient (based on a formulary of syrups or paediatric-dose tablets and a commercial cough preparation). Treatment of coughs and colds with antibiotics is not recommended in the Kenyan or in the IMCI guidelines. Compliance with existing treatment guidelines for the management of acute respiratory infections would have halved the cost of the drugs prescribed. The estimated cost of the drugs needed to treat children using the IMCI guidelines was less than the cost of the drugs actually prescribed, but varied considerably depending on the dosage forms and whether a commercial cough preparation was used.

Indexing Agency: PIP Local ID #: 147135. Indexing Agency: POP Local ID #: 00290560.
Keywords: Africa; Africa South Of The Sahara; Child Health Services*; Comparative Studies*; Cost Benefit Analysis*; Delivery Of Health Care*; Demographic Factors; Developing Countries; Drugs*; Eastern Africa; English Speaking Africa; Evaluation; Health; Health Facilities*; Health Services; Integrated Programs*; Kenya; Maternal-child Health Services; Organization And Administration; Population; Population Characteristics; Primary Health Care; Programs; Quantitative Evaluation; Research Methodology; Research Report*; Rural Health Services*; Rural Population*; Studies; Treatment
Note: TJ: BULLETIN OF THE WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION.
Local Abstract: [PIP] This study evaluated the impact of the integrated management guidelines of childhood illness (IMCI) developed by the WHO and UN Children's Fund on the treatment cost in Kenya. To determine the impact of the guidelines, a comparison was made of the cost of drugs actually prescribed to 747 sick children aged 2-59 months in rural facilities with the treatment cost had the children been managed following the IMCI guidelines. The study found that the estimated cost of drugs required to treat children following the IMCI guidelines was lower than the cost of the drugs actually prescribed in ill children. The average cost of drugs actually prescribed for every sick child was US$0.44. Antibiotics were the most expensive component, with phenoxymethylpenicillin syrup responsible for 59% of the total cost of prescribed drugs. The cost of medications that would have been prescribed had the children been treated using the guidelines ranges from US$0.16 to US$0.39 per patient. Managing cough and colds with antibiotics is not recommended in the IMCI guidelines, thus, compliance to guidelines would have reduced the treatment cost to one half the cost of drugs actually prescribed.

Date Created: 19991211 Date Completed: 20000103 Latest Revision: 20090529

20250114

PMC2557738

10593034