Analysis of the general uncertainty propagation and calculation of the systematic uncertainty of the Neumann Equation of State for surface free energy determination

The determination of the surface free energy $\gamma_{\text{SV}}$ of solid materials provides information to explain and understand a wide variety of phenomena in surface science. One of the most widely used methods to determine the value of $\gamma_{\text{SV}}$ is the Neumann equation of state (EQS), whose application requires the values of the contact angle $(\theta)$ and the surface tension of a probe liquid $\gamma_{\text{LV}}$. Both parameters are determined experimentally, and their values may be subject to considerable uncertainty. In the present work, the uncertainties of the EQS are analyzed by means of the Taylor series method, using a polynomial adjustment to the EQS previously reported. This analysis allowed us to determine the effects of the ${\theta}$ and $\gamma_{\text{LV}}$ uncertainties on $\gamma_{\text{SV}}$ values. The $\gamma_{\text{SV}}$ of polyoxymethylene (POM) and polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) was calculated using the EQS from four probe liquids and taking into account the propagation of the ${\theta}$ and $\gamma_{\text{LV}}$ uncertainties. Generally, the comparison of the $\gamma_{\text{SV}}$ values calculated from the different probe fluids revealed significant differences. As a solution to this inconsistency in the EQS method, we proposed taking into account a systematic standard uncertainty associated with the method equal to $1.3 \, \text{mJ/m}^2$ . This allowed the differences between the $\gamma_{\text{SV}}$ values for the different probe liquids to be non-significant and therefore the method to be consistent.
Comment: 46 pages, 6 tables, 10 figures