Feedback Matters: Examining the Use of Feedback Strategies by Chinese Preschool Teachers in Science Lessons

Y

17

Preschool Teachers; Feedback (Response); Science Instruction; Teacher Competencies; Teaching Skills; Foreign Countries; Preschool Education; Geographic Regions

10.1007/s10643-021-01265-3

1082-3301
1573-1707

This investigation of how Chinese preschool teachers use feedback strategies as part of Initiation, Response, and Feedback (IRF) sequences during whole-group science lessons can inform current practice. Using quantitative and qualitative data analysis, this study examined 28 videos of preschool science lessons from three regions representing above average, average, and below average levels of economic development in a southern province of China. Videotape transcriptions were coded by two trained raters using the 12 feedback strategies, offered within Classroom Assessment Scoring System (CLASS) and categorized as either Affirmation/Correction-Direct Instruction (ACDI) or Extension by Responsive Questioning (EbRQ). Among the ACDI strategies, "Specific feedback" was most frequently used. In the EbRQ category, "Follow-up questions," "Back-and-forth exchanges," and "Teacher persistence" were the most frequently used strategies, with "Asking students to explain thinking" and "Back-and-forth exchanges" shown to elicit higher-order thinking more frequently. Further feedback analysis revealed teachers' lack of contextual authenticity and insufficient leveraging of prior experiences, or of science content knowledge. Also, weak questioning skills (i.e., open-ended questions and/or higher-order questions) were related to teachers' ineffective use of feedback strategies. The results suggested that feedback matters and that teachers need to pay more attention to feedback strategies. Conclusions and critical pedagogical implications related to providing feedback for improving preschool teacher education and professional development are also offered.

As Provided

2022

EJ1353746